Heat pump or gas boiler for a small office: the 10-year numbers, 2026

Heat pump or gas boiler for a small office: the 10-year numbers, 2026

The boiler installer says a heat pump costs three times as much. The heat pump installer says it pays for itself. Both are telling the truth about their half of the invoice. The question that decides it is a ten-year one: what does each option actually cost, end to end, at real 2026 EU energy prices and honest efficiency numbers? We ran that arithmetic below for a small EU office. The heat pump wins on ten-year cost by roughly €10,000 — but it wins only under conditions you can check for yourself in about five minutes, and loses badly when those conditions are missing.

The starting prices, 2026

Every number in our model comes from published 2026 Données, not brochure estimates:

  • Gas: €0.0616/kWh. Eurostat’s EU average for non-household consumers in the 10,000–100,000 GJ band, first half of 2026, including non-recoverable taxes. A small office buys far less gas than this band implies, and the smaller bands price slightly higher — conservative for gas. The country spread is enormous: €0.04 in Bulgaria and Belgium, €0.11 in Sweden.
  • Électricité: €0.18/kWh. Eurostat EU average for businesses buying 500–2,000 MWh/year, first half of 2026. A small office on a lower band pays more — that’s the heat pump’s biggest exposure, and we test it below.
  • Gas condensing boiler: À propos 90% seasonal efficiency. Modern condensing appliances convert roughly nine-tenths of the gas into heat over a heating season; the Commission’s own heat pump support work uses a comparable figure (93%).
  • Air-source heat pump: seasonal performance factor of 3.4. Ça’s SPF, not showroom COP. The European Heat Pump Association’s technology review tracks the best tested air-water units at roughly 4.2, while field campaigns historically measured air/water systems averaging 2.6–3.4. In an office with radiators or fan coils running 55 °C flow water, 3.4 is an honest central figure; underfloor heating earns more.
  • Purchase and installation: €3,000–5,000 for a gas boiler versus €10,000–20,000 for a heat pump — the Commission’s BUILD UP platform, summarising an EU comparative study, gives exactly these brackets. We use €4,000 and €14,000: the midpoints, which also match the JRC’s heat pump cost review (air-water ≈ €10,000 installed, gas boiler ≈ €2,500, per Trinomics 2023, plus commercial overhead).
  • Entretien: gas boiler €200–350/year (annual service plus chimney sweep), heat pump €50–150/year, per the German heating-index analysis published in 2026. Both systems live well past our ten-year horizon, so no replacement is modelled.

No subsidies are modelled, because subsidy regimes are national and expire. If yours covers 30–50% of the heat pump quote, it moves every conclusion below further in the heat pump’s favour.

The ten-year table

Model office: 200 m², 250 kW·h/m²/year heat demand, 50,000 kWh of useful heat per year, ten years, prices flat (they were falling through 2026, so flat is conservative for gas-cheap scenarios and irrelevant in direction).

Cost item Gas condensing boiler (η ≈ 0.90) Air-source heat pump (SPF 3.4)
Annual energy input 55,556 kWh gas 14,706 kWh electricity
Annual energy cost €3,422 €2,647
Annual maintenance 275 € €100
Installation (one-off) €4,000 €14,000
10-year total cost €40,970 €41,470
10-year cost, heat & maintenance only (excl. install) €36,970 €27,470
10-year cost at business-tariff reality (elec. €0.15 / gas €0.07) €45,640 €37,060

Read the second block first, because that’s the argument. Running a heat pump costs about €10,600 less over ten years. Ça’s the whole case. The only thing standing between you and that money is the €10,000 installation gap — which the running savings at Eurostat averages fall about €500 short of erasing inside the decade. But use the tariff structure most small offices actually have — gas near €0.07, business electricity near €0.15, the spread real contracts carry — and the capital is recovered in about five and a half years, leaving an €8,600 heat-pump win at year ten.

The one number that decides everything: the price ratio

La Commission’s heat pump support position paper states the threshold plainly: for a heat pump to be cost-competitive to operate, electricity should cost no more than about twice the price of gas. Divide our two Eurostat averages: 0.18 ÷ 0.0616 = 2.9. At EU-average tariffs, in a 250 kWh/m² building, a heat pump with SPF 3.4 roughly breaks even over ten years after installation — the table’s €500 difference is noise.

Now plug in your own two tariffs and the ratio, and the abstract argument dies in thirty seconds. The model’s arithmetic is simple: a point of gas is worth 0.9 kWh of heat, a point of electricity is worth 3.4 kWh, and the €10,000 install gap plus €175/year of maintenance difference needs about €1,000/year of running savings to erase it over a decade. That puts the line between win and loss in three zones:

  • Ratio below 2.6 (cheap business electricity, expensive gas — parts of the Nordics, the Netherlands, Belgium): the heat pump wins the ten-year total, usually on year-one running costs too. At Belgium’s €0.0439 gas price paired with EU-average electricity, it wins outright on energy alone.
  • Ratio 2.6–3.1 (much of Central Europe, and the EU average of 2.9 itself): break-even territory — the heat pump saves running money but recovers its capital only in the last years of the decade, if at all. The decision belongs to the next section — the building — and to carbon targets, regulation direction and boiler age, not to the spreadsheet.
  • Ratio above 3.2 (some Italian, Spanish or Greek small-consumption combinations, or any SPF below 3): keep the boiler if it’s young; run the numbers again at end-of-life.

The conditions that make the SPF real

SPF 3.4 is not a promise the installer can pin to the wall; it’s a property of the system, and three things move it more than the brand of machine:

1. Flow temperature. Every 5 K you can take off the flow temperature adds 0.3–0.5 to the SPF, per the German operating-cost analysis above. A heat pump forced to make 65 °C for old radiators runs near 2.5 and loses money. A heat pump making 45 °C runs above 4. 2. Building fabric. The BUILD UP study found heat pumps most favourable in energy-class-B buildings and weakest in class C–D, where heat demand balloons. Our 250 kWh/m² office sits at the ugly end: in a 120 kWh/m² building the heat pump’s running cost nearly halves and it wins outright almost everywhere. 3. Bivalence. The cheapest hours of an office heat pump are mild hours, and they’re also the cooling hours: one machine heats in January and air-conditions in July, and dual use is a payback accelerator that gas cannot copy without buying a second machine.

What we’d actually recommend

  • Boiler younger than 8 Années? Keep it, spend €300 on tuning (heating curve, night setback), revisit at end of life. Replacing a working boiler is the most expensive way to look green.
  • Boiler at end of life in a building above 200 kWh/m² demand? Insulate and lower flow temperatures first — then a heat pump usually wins the ten-year table even before subsidies.
  • End of life, decent envelope, electricity/gas ratio under 2.6? Heat pump, and quote three installers: installation quality moves SPF more than equipment choice.
  • Anywhere a boiler is mandated anyway (process heat, kitchens with high demand hot water): hybrid — boiler plus heat pump carrying the base load — keeps the ratio argument on your side.

One direction of travel belongs in any decision that spans ten years: gas carries a carbon cost that is scheduled to rise (EU buildings pricing is on its way) while business electricity prices have fallen for six straight half-years. Flat-price tables are the conservative frame; the trend line is not flat.

Sources

  • Eurostat, « Annual fall in non-household gas prices: −6.7% » (H1 2026 EU average gas €0.06/kWh, band 10,000–100,000 GJ; country range €0.04–0.11), 4 Nov 2026: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/w/ddn-20261104-2
  • Eurostat, Natural gas price statistics (non-household EU average €0.0616/kWh, H1 2026, Incl. non-recoverable taxes): https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Natural_gas_price_statistics
  • Eurostat, « Non-household electricity prices fall further in 2026 » (H1 2026 EU average €0.18/kWh, band 500–2,000 MWh): https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/en/web/products-eurostat-news/w/ddn-20261104-1
  • BUILD UP (Commission européenne), « Heat pump or gas boiler: new study examines the most affordable alternative » (install costs €10,000–20,000 vs €2,500–5,000; efficiency by energy label): https://build-up.ec.europa.eu/en/news-and-events/news/heat-pump-or-gas-boiler-new-study-examines-most-affordable-alternative
  • JRC, « Heat pumps in the European Union » (Trinomics 2023 cost benchmarks: air-water HP ≈ €10,000, gas boiler ≈ €2,500 installed): https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC134991/JRC134991_01.pdf
  • Commission européenne, « Support Action on Heat Pumps — position paper » (electricity must cost at most about twice gas for cost-parity operation): https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/circabc-ewpp/d/d/workspace/SpacesStore/bcd1d374-9901-4c3a-be0b-add9e651c5f1/download
  • EHPA, « Integrating technologies to decarbonise heating and cooling » (SCOP/SPF per EN 14825; top air-water efficiency ≈ 4.2; gas condensing 93%): https://www.ehpa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/White_Paper_Heat_pumps-1.pdf
  • Heatpumpswatch, « Heating technologies compared » (Allemagne 2026: maintenance €50–150/yr heat pump vs €200–350/yr gas boiler; condensing efficiency ≈ 90%; flow temperature −5 K ⇒ SPF +0.3–0.5): https://heatpumpswatch.org/heating-technologies-compared/

—

Carla Lavigne est rédactrice en chef des opérations vertes chez mycompanyisgreen.org et la collègue qui apporte la calculatrice à l’audit.